X99 Motherboard Group Test: Asus, EVGA, Gigabyte and MSI

Written by Antony Leather

September 9, 2014 | 18:50

Tags: #best-2011-motherboard #best-haswell-e-motherboard #haswell-e #lga2011-v3 #x99

Companies: #asus #bit-tech #evga #gigabyte #msi

MSI X99S SLI Plus Review

Manufacturer: MSI
UK price (as reviewed): £159.95 (inc VAT)
US price (as reviewed): $229.99 (ex Tax)

As the cheapest motherboard on test, you might expect the X99S SLI Plus to miss out on many features but at face value, most actually appear to be here. Despite retailing for just £160, SATA Express and M.2 support are here and the latter has space for a single Type 2280, 2260 or 2240 device. There's even on-board power and reset buttons - something missing from the more expensive GA-X99-Gaming 5.

Click to enlarge

It's perhaps a tad bland-looking, but MSI has taken a safe approach and gone with black for everything - black heatsinks, black PCB and black ports. Even the CPU socket mechanism has been annodised black. Layout raises few issues too, with most of the SATA ports mounted at right angles to the PCB and while the 8-pin EPS 12V connector is located right next to the large VRM heatsink, it's a simple task to remove it.

Click to enlarge

If you're thinking about dropping in several graphics cards, though, MSI hasn't taken the Gigabyte and Asus approach of spacing the high-speed slots for better cooling. You're limited to the top two slots for two-card setups, not really offering enough clearance for air-cooled systems, plus you'll be covering both 1x PCI-E slots too. Again, the X99 Deluxe offers a more accessible M.2 ports thanks to its vertically mounted on-board port and add-on PCI-E card, but at this price, we commend MSI for including a full length slot in the first place.

Click to enlarge

The rear I/O panel is undeniably sparse compared to the the other ATX boards on test, although there are two more USB 3 ports compared to the GA-X99-Gaming 5, plus a CMOS clear button makes an appearance too - something the GA-X99-Gaming 5 lacks completely.

Click to enlarge

Specifications
  • Expansion slots: Four PCI-E 16x (Two x16, Two x8) Two PCI-E 1x
  • Networking: Intel Gigabit
  • SATA Express support: YES
  • M.2 Support: YES
  • Storage: 1 x M.2, 1 x SATA Express, 10 x SATA 6Gbps
  • USB: 12 x USB 3 (4 via X99 headers), 6 x USB 2 (4 via headers)
  • Audio: Realtek ALC1150


Overclocking and EFI

The X99S SLI Plus handled DIMMs at 2,666MHz out of the box fine, and we just needed to set the correct frequency in the EFI. Amazingly, it also managed to stay within limits all the way up to 4.3GHz too, needing 1.285V to get there. However, this was literally a few degrees short of throttling so we're not talking about significant advantages here.

Click to enlarge

Click to enlarge

Click to enlarge

Click to enlarge

MSI has included the usual blue/black EFI colour scheme of its budget motherboards, although this isn't too dissimilar to its MPower and Gaming-branded offerings. It's clear and is perhaps the most easy to use of all the EFI's on test, at least as far as mainstream overclocking goes.
Discuss this in the forums

Posted by Anfield - Tue Sep 09 2014 20:06

What do little Pc components dream of being when they grow up?

Asus X99 Deluxe.

Just a shame the platform as a whole rips such deep holes in bank accounts, so I'll be patiently waiting for Broadwell or even Skylake.

Posted by GuilleAcoustic - Tue Sep 09 2014 21:30

jrs77
Yeah, even with the i7-5820k the cheapest 4x4GB DDR4 and the cheapest X99-board you're looking at €750. And you'll need a dedicated GPU.

An i7-4790k paired with quality 4x4GB DDR3 and a decent board you'll only pay €550 and you can use the IGP if you don't need a dedicated GPU.

Singlethreaded the 4790k beats the 2011-3 parts and not too many applications make any good use of more threads thus far, allthough we're waiting for multithreaded software a couple of years now allready.

I was really tempted buying the small 6C/12t 5820k to build a workstation with, but it simply isn't reasonable to do so compared to an 1150-i7 system.

These new 2011-3 systems are for people, who have money to waste currently, but they're not a reasonable choice imho.
I'm 100% with you :D. Number of cores appart, the main difference between 1150 i7 and 2011-3 are the maximum number of PCIe lanes available (only with high end 2011-3 CPU). Not really worth it and still won't beat an LGA1150 ITX farm.

Posted by t5kcannon - Tue Sep 09 2014 21:32

Anfield
What do little Pc components dream of being when they grow up?

Asus X99 Deluxe.

Just a shame the platform as a whole rips such deep holes in bank accounts, so I'll be patiently waiting for Broadwell or even Skylake.
Yes the new X99 stuff, which is packed with features, is on the costly side. Mind you, new tech tends to come at a premium. Can only hope prices drop.
null
YouTube logo
MSI MPG Velox 100R Chassis Review

October 14 2021 | 15:04

In line with recent changes to data protection legislation in the UK and Europe we would like to direct you to our updated Privacy Policy here.